Tuesday, October 27, 2026

It's Just a Failed Economy

It's over and even the fraud knows it:

The federal government may be on track to take in almost$20-billion more in taxes and other revenue this year than had been expected less than six months ago, National Post has learned, potentially handing Prime Minister Mark Carney much more room in his second budget to cut taxes, trim Canada’s massive deficit or spend.

In its Spring Economic Update in late April, the government said it expected to rake in $529.6-billion this fiscal year, which would have been an increase of 3.5 per cent over the previous year.

But instead, according to government figures up to the most recent month, Ottawa has so far this year taken in 7.4 per cent more than the previous year, more than double the pace of growth that had been expected. If the growth continues throughout the year, that translates to $549.4-billion, or $19.8-billion more than what had been expected in April.

Economists say the federal government, like the provinces and territories, is sitting on extra cash this year due to higher-than expected income tax payments, a small jump in inflation, and strong markets for many natural resources, particularly oil. That means increases in both corporate income tax and sales tax.

Trevor Tombe, professor of economics at the University of Calgary and director of fiscal and economic policy at the School of Public Policy, said he’s surprised at the federal government’s revenue spike, although he emphasized that Ottawa shouldn’t assume that those increases will continue.

Canada’s trade relationship with the U.S. remains uncertain while growth has been sluggish and the government’s fiscal situation is dire, leading to questions about how long the revenue spike will continue, economists say.

 

(Sidebar: this US.) 

 

He squeezed blood out of a stone.

Good for him.

** 

Although crude exports have meaningfully recovered, supply is still below demand, shipping costs have skyrocketed and refined product exports from the Middle East have risen much more slowly. On top of that, Ukraine has been relentlessly and successfully attacking Russian refineries. While Russia normally exports as much as half of its fuel oil output, production constraints have led it to go so far as to ban diesel exports. Diesel prices around the world have hit record highs and shortages are likely persist into 2027.

Why do these conflicts affect Canadian fuel prices? Canada is not only a large exporter of crude oil, it is a net exporter of finished petroleum products such as diesel and gasoline. However, the fuel market is global. Diesel prices in Canada are determined by the value of diesel in the North American and global markets, not Canada’s domestic balance of production and consumption. Canadian and American refiners respond to international shortages by moving more diesel into markets where it is more scarce, and thus can fetch higher prices.

This normal market response has provoked accusations from the B.C. and federal NDP that refiners are exploiting overseas conflicts and war profiteering. There have even been calls for capping diesel prices and windfall profit taxes. This is not a phenomenon exclusive to the left. U.S. President Donald Trump, being particularly sensitive to the impact of high diesel prices on the upcoming midterm elections, has also floated the idea of an export ban on diesel.

Yet such ideas would exacerbate the current crisis, as they would restrict markets rather than increasing supply, and discourage more North American refining. At a time when the world needs more diesel, the priority should be maximizing Canadian refinery throughput and keeping trade flowing, not restricting access to the supplies that remain.

Canada can do little in the short term to alleviate the global energy crisis, but provincial and federal governments have other tools to lower prices at the pump, as up to 40 per cent of the cost of a litre of gas comes from taxes.

The low hanging fruit has been addressed by the federal government: in addition to removing the consumer carbon tax in 2025, Prime Minister Mark Carney suspended the federal fuel excise tax in April, saving Canadians 10 cents/litre on gasoline and four cents/litre on diesel. Alberta and Prince Edward Island have also suspended provincial fuel taxes.

But there is another lever to pull: the clean fuel regulations. Enacted in 2023, the clean fuel regulations (CFR) are designed to progressively reduce the greenhouse gas emissions associated with gasoline and diesel sold in Canada.

Rather than imposing a fixed charge per litre, they require suppliers to reduce the life-cycle carbon intensity of the fuels they sell through a complicated combination of tradable credit markets, life-cycle emissions accounting and different compliance pathways. Blending in lower-carbon fuels such as ethanol and biodiesel is one of the principal pathways.

Although the CFR is not as transparent as an excise tax, we know how much it costs consumers because Atlantic-Canadian fuel prices are regulated, and most provincial regulators explicitly allow suppliers to recover compliance costs in gasoline and diesel prices.

In July, the Nova Scotia regulator assessed the CFR compliance costs at 13.57 cents a litre for diesel and 12.24 cents a litre for gasoline. To add insult to injury, HST is charged on top of these costs. The Parliamentary Budget Officer estimated in 2023 that the cost of the CFR would rise to 17 cents per litre of gasoline and 16 cents per litre of diesel by 2030, and lower Canada’s GDP by 0.3 per cent.

There is an even more insidious aspect to the CFR. To meet their carbon intensity targets, many Canadian refiners blend biofuels into their petroleum products. But Canada is not self-sufficient in their production. More than half of Canada’s biofuels are imported, predominantly from the United States.

Somehow, in the middle of a trade war and an energy crisis, it has gone unnoticed that Canada — the aspiring energy superpower — has artificially made itself dependent on the United States for fuel. The vulnerability was brutally exposed with U.S. President Donald Trump’s diesel export ban threat, when refiners were scrambling to find out if renewable diesel bound for Canada would be caught in the net.

It is a favourite line of the Carney government that, amidst geopolitical rupture and trade disruption, “Canada is focused on what we can control.” The CFR is at the top of the list of self-harming, expensive and distortive policies that Canada controls, and has every interest in rolling back.

** 

The next time you pull up to the gas pump and grumble about the soaring cost of filling up the tank, take solace you don’t live in Norway or Mexico.

Those two countries are among a number of energy-producing democratic nations whose gas prices are far higher than what Canadians pay, according to an analysis by Benchmark Canada, a Macdonald-Laurier Institute project that compares Canada with its peers.

Which doesn’t make it cheap. Canadians paid an average of about $1.85 a litre for gas by mid-October, the Benchmark Canada data shows, but that’s less than Norway, the United Kingdom, Australia and Mexico. Only Americans, who pay the cheapest at roughly $1.57 a litre in equivalent Canadian dollars, and Brazilians pay less for gas.

In almost all the countries surveyed, government taxes and policy are driving higher prices.

“The underlying cost of the commodity is roughly the same,” said Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy. “It may vary slightly, but it’s all in taxes and potential rules and regulations.”

Taxes make up about 21 per cent of the Canadian pump price at normal rates (17 per cent if you take account of the federal excise tax, which is suspended until next January). In Norway, which has more oil per person than any other of the seven democracies highlighted by Benchmark Canada, they make up 51 per cent, the data showed. Again, American drivers enjoy the lowest gas tax at about 12 per cent.

 

 That's not all we over-spend for:

Canada spends the second-highest share of its economy on health care among 32 countries with universal or systems, yet ranks near the bottom for the availability of doctors, hospital beds, and much of its medical technology, according to a recent study.

The study, conducted by the Fraser Institute, examines how Canada compares with other high-income countries in health-care spending, resource availability, and access to medical services.

After adjusting for differences in the age of each country’s population, Canada ranked second-highest in health-care spending as a percentage of GDP in 2024, the most recent year for which comparable data were available. Canada spent 11.9 percent of GDP on health care, behind Chile at 12.6 percent.

Despite the high spending, the study found that Canada generally has fewer medical resources per capita than many comparable countries.

The report is a 2026 update to a long-standing series that began in 2002. Its main data sources include OECD databases, the Canadian Institute for Health Information, and the Commonwealth Fund, a U.S.-based private foundation focused on health-care policy.

The 32 countries included in the study are OECD members, have universal or near-universal coverage for core medical services, and are classified as high-income countries by the World Bank.

 

At this time, some Canadian parrot would repeat the often-heard line that at least we are not the US, a tired refrain that serves to distract rather than address why we spend more for rationed care than for medical professionals and necessary medicines.  

 

The EU can save us, right?:

 

Oh.

 

Also:

 

 But ... engineers who drive Ubers ...

 


No comments: