Tuesday, July 04, 2023

We Don't Have to Trade With China

Yet we do:

An ad hoc committee of parliamentarians has begun its probe into previously withheld documents related to the firing of two infectious-disease scientists from Canada’s highest-security lab in Winnipeg, according to a report.
“Work is underway and documents are available to the committee members. They work independently,” said Mark Kennedy, communications director for Government House Leader Mark Holland, according to the Globe and Mail on June 29.
Kennedy said the special parliamentary committee has begun its investigation and will receive unfettered access to all national-security documents related to the eviction of Xiangguo Qiu and her husband Keding Cheng from the National Microbiology Laboratory (NML) in January 2021.
The couple was first escorted out of the NML facilities in July 2019 and stripped of their security clearances.
**

A researcher at the Wuhan Institute of Virology claimed that China deliberately developed the COVID-19 virus as a "bioweapon."

Researcher Chao Shao said during an interview with reporter and activist Jennifer Zeng this week that his fellow lab researchers were given different strains of coronaviruses and asked to determine which is most effective for spreading across various species.

Shao further claimed that the whereabouts of several of his colleagues could not be determined during the 2019 Military World Games in Wuhan and that some of them were sent to hotels where international athletes were living to "check the health or hygiene conditions."

Shao said he thinks his colleagues were sent to the hotels to spread the coronavirus, ...

**

There is now a Chinese invasion of the U.S. homeland.

Chinese migrants are entering the United States on foot at the southern border. Almost all are desperate, seeking a better life for themselves and their children. Some, however, are coming to commit acts of sabotage.

Many [Chinese], however, are short-circuiting the long waits at the consulates. At the southern border, Chinese migrants are entering the United States in unprecedented numbers.

Once here, the military fighters can link up with China's agents already in place or Chinese diplomats.

How many of the PLA fighters have slipped into the United States this way? Some estimate 5,000, others 10,000. Those numbers sound high, but whatever the actual figure more are coming.

These are China's shock troops. The concern is that, on the first day of war in Asia they will take down America's power lines, poison reservoirs, assassinate officials, start wildfires, spread pathogens, and create terror by bombing shopping malls and supermarkets.

The saboteurs will almost certainly attack American military bases. China has already been probing sensitive installations. Chinese agents posing as tourists have, for instance, intruded into bases, including the Army's Fort Wainwright in Fairbanks, Alaska.

"When the Chinese Communist Party starts its war against Taiwan and the United States, Americans should expect that Chinese sleeper agents now in America will hit targets like gas stations and military-age Chinese now crossing our border will be mobilized for assassination attacks and assaults on U.S. military bases." — Richard Fisher, International Assessment and Strategy Center, to Gatestone, June 17, 2023

[T]he next war in Asia will almost certainly be fought on U.S. soil, perhaps on its first day. Unsuspecting Americans will be in the fight.

Immigrants make countries strong, and almost all the Chinese migrants crossing the southern border will contribute to American society. Some, however, are coming to wage war on the United States.

**

The Laurentian Elite has always been a friend of the country that kills its political dissidents and steals their organs:

A million-dollar bounty being offered by Hong Kong police for the capture of exiled democratic activists has supporters renewing calls for Canada’s former chief justice Beverley McLachlin to resign from the region’s highest court, saying her continued presence legitimizes China’s persecution of activists.

Advertisement 2

STORY CONTINUES BELOW

Article content

“I don’t understand what she’s thinking. She is a well-respected judge in Canada and internationally… I don’t know why she would try to ruin her reputation at the end of her career like this,” said Benjamin Fung, a McGill University professor and spokesperson for pro-democracy group Action Free Hong Kong Montreal.

“She needs to terminate her contract and come back to Canada.”

McLachlin’s presence on the Hong Kong Final Court of Appeal has grown increasingly controversial since she first accepted the appointment in 2018, after China soon began moving in on Hong Kong, which had previously enjoyed special democratic freedoms, and began cracking down and imprisoning dissidents.

On Tuesday, Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee announced the bounty on the eight pro-democracy activists living in self-imposed exile in the United States, Britain and Australia. Lee said that activists Nathan Law, Ted Hui, Dennis Kwok, Kevin Yam, Mung Siu-tat, Finn Lau, Anna Kwok and Elmer Yuen, would be “pursued for life” and should “surrender” to Chinese authorities.

“Beverley McLachlin is basically supporting a farce by Hong Kong,” said Cheuk Kwan, co-chair of the Toronto Association for Democracy in China “There’s no other way to describe this, it’s like the Wild West.”

McLachlin did not respond to a call, voicemail or text message requesting comment Tuesday.

**

Demonstrators attending an anti-discrimination rally on Parliament Hill played the Chinese People’s Liberation Army anthem, says a pro-democracy China media monitor. The anthem pledged allegiance to “Mao Zedong’s flag.”



Your Incompetent Government and You

It's like a nepotistic gift that keeps on giving:

Michael Wernick, former chief clerk of the federal public service, yesterday joined a Liberal-affiliated think tank. Wernick abruptly resigned in 2019 following disclosures of cabinet’s failed attempt to quash a criminal prosecution of SNC-Lavalin Group Inc.: “I worry about the reputations of honourable people who have served their country being besmirched.”

**

The federal government’s national dental care plan—introduced as a condition of its supply and confidence agreement with the NDP—will cost more than $10 billion over the next five years, says Parliamentary Budget Officer (PBO) Yves Giroux.

The Liberal government introduced its “New Canadian Dental Care Plan” as part of the 2023 budget tabled by Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland in late March.

The government allocated $13 billion for the program over the next five years, which was more than double the $6 billion that Ottawa had originally budgeted for the program.

The government’s plan, which it intends to begin by the end of 2023, will be aimed at initially providing dental coverage for uninsured Canadians under the age of 18, persons with disabilities, and seniors whose annual family income is less than $90,000.

By 2025, the government plans to extend the program to cover all uninsured Canadians with an annual family income under $90,000.

Giroux’s office published a legislative costing note for the program on June 28, saying that he anticipates it will “increase federal program spending by $10.1 billion over five years.”

The PBO said his estimate—which is $2.9 billion lower than what the federal government estimated the program would cost in Budget 2023—is based on the assumption that the provinces and territories will continue to provide any of their existing dental care programs in the future.

However, Giroux said that if the provinces and territories “reduce or eliminate” any of their dental coverage programs, the cost of the federal government’s new dental care plan would increase by nearly another $5 billion over five years.

**

Two days before the Clean Fuel Regulation (CFR) was enforced, Alberta’s Minister of Environment and Protected Areas Rebecca Schulz wrote to federal Minister of Environment and Climate Change Steven Guilbeault, calling on his government to “immediately halt” the implementation of the new policy.
Schulz said the policy will “harm provincial economies” in Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Atlantic Canada.
“Canadians are already struggling with high inflation. Adding fuel to the fire by hiking the cost of gasoline and diesel will be devastating,” she said in her letter on June 29.
“A plan that unfairly increases costs on families and does not account for regional differences is no plan at all.”

That is the plan.
**

Roughly half of all trips by the country’s biggest airline _ including its lower-cost Air Canada Rouge and regional partner Jazz Aviation — were disrupted Saturday through Monday, according to figures from tracking service FlightAware.

The 1,965 flight delays and cancellations — over 52 per cent of scheduled flights — stand in contrast to numbers from other Canadian carriers including WestJet, Air Transat and Flair Airlines, which registered lower flight disruption levels.

They also mark an uptick from the previous weekend, despite an unexpected shortage of air traffic controllers at Nav Canada that snarled travel during that period.

Posts and photos of snaking lines and bulging terminals at airports in Toronto and Montreal popped up on social media over the past few days, as passengers vented their frustrations about late takeoffs and customer service in a throwback to scenes of post-pandemic airport chaos a year ago.

**

A rebate is simply money the government has stolen from you and partially given back in small increments:

The one-time rebate is aimed at helping 11 million low- and modest-income Canadians and families offset the cost of food at grocery stores, which has risen more than 11 per cent in the past year.
The grocery rebate payment will be administered through the GST rebate system. Eligible Canadians will start receiving payments on July 5, in line with already-scheduled quarterly GST rebates, said the Canada Revenue Agency.
Who is eligible for the rebate? 
The eligibility is based on household income and family size, same as for the GST tax credit.
The rebate is designed for individuals who make $32,000 or less and families who make $38,000 or less.
How do I get the rebate? 
The rebate will be issued automatically. You don’t need to apply for this separately.


We wouldn't want the masses to riot over the summer, would we?


Also:

Inflation has overtaken the Canada Food Guide, says the federal department responsible for benchmark guidance on healthy eating. Less than a third of Canadians can afford minimum daily servings of fruit and vegetables, it said: “The Food Guide was released prior to the recent rising cost of food due to inflation and does not currently acknowledge the growing issues of food availability and affordability.”

**

Over 325 Canadians—among them, doctors, journalists, lawyers, and ordinary citizens—testified about the harms that government policies such as lockdowns, mask mandates, and COVID-19 vaccines brought.

Several doctors, researchers, and professors were highly critical of COVID-19 vaccines, arguing they were not properly tested and resulted in many injuries and deaths. Canadian researcher Jessica Rose said drug companies rushed their vaccine trials and failed to account for factors such as long-term data and safety and efficacy; mRNA pioneer Dr. Robert Malone said COVID vaccines have been shown to damage the brain, as well as the endocrine and reproductive systems of its recipients; and Dr. Joseph Fraiman showed that Pfizer and Moderna COVID-19 vaccines were associated with an excess risk of serious adverse events of special interest in about one in every 565 people.

Meanwhile, several medical professors testified that potential treatments for the disease were ignored or actively discouraged. Alberta physician Daniel Nagase claimed success in treating COVID-19 patients with ivermectin, but Health Canada disagreed, stating there was no evidence for ivermectin’s effectiveness and it was unauthorized for that use, and he was later removed from medical duty after administering ivermectin to his final patient. Psychiatrist Greg Passey also questioned the lack of emphasis governments and public health authorities placed on potential treatments for COVID-19, such as ivermectin.

Canada’s news media received considerable criticism during the NCI hearings. Rodney Palmer, a former journalist with multiple outlets, labeled news media’s pandemic reporting as “propaganda,” arguing they heavily favoured narratives put forth by the federal government and corporations. Marianne Klowak, a former CBC reporter of 34 years, also accused the network of silencing one side of the COVID-19 debate while portraying it as “dangerous” and spreading misinformation.

**

The Public Health Agency claims 20 times more Canadians would have died in the pandemic than in World War Two if not for lockdowns and vaccine mandates. The claim is detailed in briefing notes and a “what could have happened” study self-published by the Agency: “Do we have data?”

**

The damage caused by this legislation and the government’s decision to ignore the potential consequences therefore run into the hundreds of millions of dollars for Canadian news outlets, effectively undoing years of public support for the sector. The government heard directly from some publishers who warned that losing the links could force them to shut down their businesses given lost links and cancelled deals. Yet it somehow decided it was comfortable putting those businesses at risk as if tough talk would somehow pay the bills.
 

There is more:

Cabinet’s costly $595 million media bailout failed to save jobs and included only “temporary” measures, says a briefing note for Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez. Heavily-subsidized newspapers cut jobs while the only significant growth in media occurred with unsubsidized digital startups, wrote staff: “Overall job losses have continued upwards.”


Also - let it ALL come out:

The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) must face a defamation lawsuit by a U.S. charity alleging the publicly funded news outlet repeatedly aired false claims that it deceived its donors, a Washington, D.C., federal judge has ruled.

U.S. District Judge Randolph D. Moss on Tuesday rejected the CBC's bid to dismiss the case on the grounds that a Canadian court would be the more appropriate venue.

WE Charity, which once operated in Canada but is suing through its U.S. affiliate based in upstate New York, alleged in its February 2022 complaint that the CBC knowingly aired false claims that the nonprofit inflated the number of schoolhouses it had built in Kenya and deceived donors about how their money was being spent, among other things.

**

Let them fight:

Business groups across Canada have sounded the alarm about the potential economic impact of the strike, which affects thousands of cargo loaders and 49 of the province’s waterfront employers at more than 30 ports across the province.

In response to calls for back-to-work legislation, a spokesman for Labour Minister Seamus O’Regan said in a statement that the federal government is not looking past the bargaining table because the best deals are made there.

**

Oh, Barbie ... :

Foreign Affairs Minister Melanie Joly said Tuesday she is concerned about the safety of India’s diplomats following the distribution of what she called “unacceptable” posters advertising upcoming protests near Toronto and Vancouver.


Sikh extremists have been freely operating in this country since the bombing of Air India 182.

"Unacceptable" is the only big word Diplomat Barbie can muster.


Also:

“Barbie” film fans in Vietnam will have to dream of seeing the doll from their childhoods come to life on the silver screen after the government banned the live-action movie for showing a map of China’s claims to territory in the disputed South China Sea.

The fantasy-comedy film, which stars Margot Robbie as Barbie and Ryan Gosling as Ken, was originally slated for a July 21 release, but it was banned from release in the communist country after the Culture Ministry’s Department of Cinema found that it contained scenes featuring China’s so-called nine-dash line, state and local media reported.

**

"I'm too stupid to do my job" is a going excuse:

Emails released to The Canadian Press through the Access to Information Act appear to show Correctional Service of Canada Commissioner Anne Kelly was not clear on how or why Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino had not been informed before Bernardo was moved out of maximum security.
The public safety minister and his staff have been under heavy scrutiny over the past month as more details have emerged about the timeline of the prison transfer. The Conservatives have demanded that Mendicino resigns over it.
The emails show Kelly herself wrote on May 26 to Public Safety Canada’s deputy minister Shawn Tupper and associate deputy minister Tricia Geddes.
“I had said I would confirm the transfer with you. It will occur next week,” Kelly wrote in an email with “High Profile Offender” in the subject line.
She told them the federal Public Safety Department, Mendicino’s office, the Privy Council Office and the Prime Minister’s Office “have been advised” and that “we have media lines ready.”
Tupper replied just minutes later to thank Kelly for the confirmation.
Bernardo is serving a life sentence for the kidnapping, torture and murders of 15-year-old Kristen French and 14-year-old Leslie Mahaffy in the early 1990s near St. Catharines, Ont. He was also convicted of manslaughter in the December 1990 death of 15-year-old Tammy Homolka, the younger sister of his then-wife, Karla Homolka. Bernardo also ultimately admitted to sexually assaulting 14 other women.

Like the legal system wasn't bad enough.


Saturday, July 01, 2023

It Was A Good Run While It Lasted

 Yep.

What is there to be proud of?

A blackface-wearing moron who runs at the first sign of trouble, bankrupts a country, controls its news feeds for fun, lets China infiltrate all levels of government and sponges off of the taxpayers and a foundation his dad started because the father knew that he and his uglier and equally useless brother cannot survive on their own?

A country that thrives on nepotism?

Or the ovine masses who do not know their own history and define themselves by how American they are not?

This wasn't the country I grew up in.

Canada was more than a place. It was a home.

Now, it's an airport, a port of entry before the fleecing majority move to the US, and  - worse - a carcass to be picked over by plutocrats and kleptocrats alike.

**

However, the organizers have used the act and its anniversary to promote opposition to proposed legislation to create a foreign agent registry in Canada, with one calling the bill “Exclusion 2.0,” a reference to the 1923 legislation, which is also known as the Chinese Exclusion Act.
According to a video posted on WeChat, the demonstrators, who appear to be senior citizens, wore red jackets and paraded in military style on Wellington Street during the protest.
The protesters moved in sync with music from a loudspeaker playing the “March of the People’s Liberation Army,” the military anthem of the Chinese army. A female voice in the clip can be heard saying in Chinese, “Golden Years, Ottawa Parliament Hill parade. Start!”
The Chinese characters “Golden Years” was visible on the back of the participants jackets as they performed a dance in front of the Parliament Buildings prior to the parade, according to a video taken by Chinese Headline New Media.
The Epoch Times previously reported that organizers of the protest had called for support of a petition against establishing a foreign influence registry in Canada.

 **

Along with the April 2016 meeting, which was first reported by Montreal’s La Presse newspaper in April 2022, documents obtained through access to information indicate the foundation held another meeting in the building in January 2016 and a subsequent one in March 2017.
All three meetings pertained to the foundation discussing its “Pluralism Project,” aimed at proving the economic benefits of diversity and inclusion with senior government officials.
Interest in the Trudeau Foundation and its links to Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has grown in recent months in the context of Chinese regime interference in Canada. The Globe and Mail reported in February that Beijing directed a Chinese Communist Party adviser in 2014 to make a donation to the foundation to curry favour with Trudeau, who went on to become prime minister in 2015.
Since becoming Liberal Party leader in 2013, Trudeau has denied any links to the foundation set up in the name of his father.
But MPs from every opposition party have suggested that the foundation benefited from privileged access to Langevin Block, which sits across from Parliament Hill. Trudeau renamed the building Office of the Prime Minister and Privy Council in 2017 because its original namesake, Hector Langevin, one of the fathers of Confederation, had a role in the residential school system.
Morris Rosenberg, president of the foundation at the time, was questioned about the April 2016 meeting when he testified before the House of Commons ethics committee on May 2.
“It was actually quite surprising to see that the Pierre Elliott Trudeau Foundation was in the Prime Minister’s building with access to five deputy ministers. That is not a common occurrence,” said Bloc Québécois MP René Villemure during Rosenberg’s testimony.
“It may not be a common occurrence, but the Langevin Building is located in downtown Ottawa, so it is very central and it is a place where senior officials often meet,” said Rosenberg, a former senior public servant who worked at the Privy Council Office (PCO), the prime minister’s department.

**

Staff in a briefing note to Foreign Minister Mélanie Joly complained media coverage of misconduct by Chinese agents has been “very negative.” The analysis noted the Prime Minister was openly criticized “for appearing to be weak.”

**

An ad hoc committee of parliamentarians has begun its probe into previously withheld documents related to the firing of two infectious-disease scientists from Canada’s highest-security lab in Winnipeg, according to a report.
“Work is underway and documents are available to the committee members. They work independently,” said Mark Kennedy, communications director for Government House Leader Mark Holland, according to the Globe and Mail on June 29.
Kennedy said the special parliamentary committee has begun its investigation and will receive unfettered access to all national-security documents related to the eviction of Xiangguo Qiu and her husband Keding Cheng from the National Microbiology Laboratory (NML) in January 2021.
The couple was first escorted out of the NML facilities in July 2019 and stripped of their security clearances.
CBC News later obtained documents through an Access to Information request showing that Qiu had been in charge of shipping the deadly Ebola and Henipah viruses to the Wuhan Institute of Virology in China in 2019.
Holland said in November 2022 that the committee probing the scientists’ eviction from the lab would also have access to documents involving the virus transfers, although the Public Health Agency of Canada previously denied any connection between Qiu and Cheng’s firing and the shipment of viruses to China.

** 

Shareef Abdelhaleem, dubbed a “principal architect” of a terror plot to blow up several Greater Toronto Area landmarks in 2006, has been granted full parole as is no longer considered an “unacceptable risk to society.”

In a decision Wednesday by the Parole Board of Canada, Abdelhaleem will no longer be under correctional supervision and only has two conditions that he must abide by: not to be in a position of responsibility or leadership in any religious or spiritual groups, and not to associate with any person known to be involved in criminal and/or radicalized activity.

“Given your overall progress, your CMT (case management team) is of the opinion that your release plan is realistic, structured, gradual and can be endorsed because it currently contains the necessary steps to achieve your objectives,” the board said in its decison.

“Therefore, it believes that you are ready and have reached the goals to be granted full parole.”

Abdelhaleem, 47, was sentenced in 2011 to life without parole for 10 years as part of the infamous Toronto 18 bomb plotters. He was the last of 11 convicted, with seven others released without charges.

** 

A $133,822 grant application by anti-Semitic activist Laith Marouf raised “no flags” at the Department of Canadian Heritage since paperwork was submitted in his wife’s name, records show. MPs protested funding for Marouf after he was banned from Twitter for fantasizing about shooting Jews: “If the individual’s views had been discovered the project would not have been funded.”

**

To celebrate Canada’s 156th birthday, the Trudeau government is introducing their second carbon tax known as the Clean Fuel Regulations. The stated goal is to lower carbon emissions in Canada through regulations on industry, but the result is the price on fossil fuels like gas, diesel and home heating fuels will go up.

** 

But you voted for it, Maritimes.

You voted for it:

New regulations that come into force everywhere in Canada on Saturday will require gasoline and diesel refineries and importers to start cutting down the amount of greenhouse-gas emissions that come from their products.

The situation is particularly heated on Canada’s East Coast, because on the same day, the four Atlantic provinces will move from their own provincial carbon-pricing systems to the national carbon levy.

That is creating a double cost whammy for consumers at the gas pump, particularly in Nova Scotia where the outgoing provincial cap-and-trade system wasn’t adding to gas prices anywhere near the amount required by the federal system.

 **

Sir John A. Macdonald called the Senate “a place of sober second thought,” which may have reflected his appreciation for at least occasional sobriety. But Bill S-243, the “Climate-Aligned Finance Act,” is the antithesis of thoughtful reconsideration. Its declared purpose is to regulate investment practices so as to reduce the risks both that financial institutions pose to the climate and that climate change poses to financial institutions. In fact, it would undermine free markets, with potentially debilitating consequences for financial institutions, the energy sector and the Canadian economy in general.

**

Swedish manufacturer Northvolt AB is close to a deal to build an electric-vehicle battery plant near Montreal, a project that’s expected to be worth about C$7 billion ($5.3 billion), according to people familiar with the matter. 

The Canadian and Quebec governments are preparing to give financial aid to Northvolt that may be worth billions, following a similar agreement with Volkswagen AG to build an EV battery plant in Ontario, the people said. An announcement is likely to be made in the coming weeks, though negotiators are still working on final details, they said, speaking on condition they not be identified because the matter is private. 

A deal with Northvolt would underscore Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s ambitions for Canada to capture a sizable piece of the North American electric-vehicle supply chain, at a huge cost to the public purse. Trudeau’s government, and the government of Ontario, have pledged more than C$14 billion to Volkswagen for its proposed factory in St. Thomas, Ontario. They’re also in talks with Stellantis NV on a EV battery plant in the city of Windsor, Ontario, across the border from Detroit.

**

It was a shakedown:

Google Canada yesterday joined Facebook in confirming it will halt all links to Canadian news content in protest over cabinet’s Bill C-18 the Online News Act. The announcement came only days after Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez said the Canadian market was too “important to them” to retaliate: ‘You have to understand they make a lot of money in Canada.’

 

This shakedown:

Google will pull Canadian news from Google Search and its other products in Canada over legislation that would force it to share revenues with news publishers, the company announced Thursday.

“We have now informed the Government that when the law takes effect, we unfortunately will have to remove links to Canadian news from our Search, News and Discover products in Canada,” Google said in a blog post.

It will also kill existing deals with publishers. “C-18 will also make it untenable for us to continue offering our Google News Showcase product in Canada,” it said.

The Online News Act received royal assent earlier this month. It would force Meta and Google to reach commercial deals with news publishers to share revenues for news stories that appear on their platforms (Postmedia, publisher of the National Post, is in favour of the legislation).

The Parliamentary Budget Officer has estimated that under the bill, which is aimed at the two companies, Google and Meta could end up funding more than 30 per cent of newsroom costs, just under $330 million a year. But if Google and Meta remove news from their platforms, they will no longer be covered under the Online News Act.

That means publishers won’t be getting additional funding, and will also lose an undisclosed sum in existing deals. In Canada, Google has signed deals with news publishers that cover 150 outlets through its Google News Showcase program, including with Postmedia. Google pays news outlets to licence content for the program, though the financial terms of the deals with outlets haven’t been disclosed.

While the Liberal government initially said it was in talks with both Google and Meta, a Meta spokesperson said this week the company isn’t negotiating and is sticking with its plans to block news content on its Facebook and Instagram platforms. It has also begun cancelling existing deals with news publishers, including The Canadian Press.

 **

There is no deal.

Whatever dreck is out there, it should be up to the individual to sift through, not a government horrified that someone out there knows that it is a mass of incompetence and greed:

Von Finckenstein said the bill was based on a flawed premise, that Google and Meta benefit from news links posted to their platforms, when it’s actually the news outlet that benefits. But Google and Meta do benefit from the data they collect from news content, von Finckenstein argued in a recent paper co-authored with Peter Menzies, who formerly served as CRTC vice chair and before that was publisher of the Calgary Herald.
Menzies pointed out in an interview the fund would give Meta and Google certainty about how much they could be expected to pay, which is one of the key concerns they’ve expressed about the current bill. And, unlike opting out of the Online News Act, there would be no way for the companies to escape from it.

Article content

Meta has said there is no compromise solution under the current bill, and that it’s no longer negotiating with the government. While Google initially entered into last-minute talks with Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez, the company said Thursday those talks weren’t successful in addressing its concerns.
Menzies said the companies could be “talked into” a compromise of a news fund, provided the contribution is reasonable. “If you make it make sense from a business point of view, you can do it.”

**

I believe that was the plan, sir:

The damage caused by the government’s Bill C-18 continues to grow as Meta has started to cancel its existing agreements with Canadian publishers. The move should not come as a surprise since any deals that involve facilitating access to news content would bring the company into the legislative framework and mandate payments for links. Indeed, Meta said earlier this week that its 18 existing deals “did not have much of a future.” When this is coupled with a reported “impasse” between the government and Google over its approach to Bill C-18, the risks to the Canadian media sector look increasingly dire. 

This was entirely foreseeable, yet Canadian Heritage Minister Pablo Rodriguez never seemed to take the risks seriously. It raises the question of whether the government developed estimates of the cost of its legislation if Meta and Google chose to comply by stopping news sharing or linking. While there were estimates for the benefits of new deals that ran into the hundreds of millions of dollars, did it conduct a risk assessment of the economic costs that would come from Internet companies exiting the news market in Canada?

There are obviously costs that extend far beyond the economics that include reduced access to news, increased prominence of low quality news sources, harm to the Canadian Internet, and the reputational damage to a government that handled this about as incompetently as possible. But from a pure economic perspective, the risks were always understated as they extended beyond just the value of increased traffic to publishers from the links they were themselves posting. Both Google and Meta have deals with Canadian publishers reportedly worth millions of dollars. As Meta’s step to begin cancelling deals suggests, those agreements are unlikely to survive the decision to exit news in Canada.


 

Happy Feast Days!

 

The Most Precious Blood of Jesus.

 



Saint Junipero Serra, patron saint of California missions.

Now, a musical interlude:


 

 

And various other holy people we should remember.