Tuesday, November 17, 2026

It's Just An Economy

Mark Carney's American stocks will do just fine:

Prime Minister Mark Carney’s claim to have found $60 billion in savings represents an in-house shift in government spending and not a net cut in spending, the Commons government operations committee said yesterday. No budget analyst to date has verified Carney’s claim that he would “save Canadian taxpayers a total of $60 billion.”

** 

With the Carney government pledging more than half a billion dollars in aid to Brazil over the weekend, it marked one of the largest sums of money Canada has ever given away to a richer country.

On the sidelines of the ASEAN Summit in Manila on Sunday, Prime Minister Mark Carney announced $560 million for the Tropical Forest Forever Facility, a Brazilian-run fund that provides financial compensation to governments which don’t develop their rainforests.

“Canada is taking ambitious action to protect the ecosystems that sustain our communities, our livelihoods, and our prosperity,” read a statement by the Prime Minister’s Office, which noted that the $560 million is part of $13 billion in climate aid earmarked for developing countries over the next five years.

 

Is this a scam? 

** 

Michael Chong is the fiscal conservative that he says Mark Carney is pretending to be.

“The prime minister is not a fiscal conservative,” Chong says calmly. The Conservative shadow minister of finance has represented Wellington-Halton Hills North since 2004. In question period he is the rare politician who finishes his sentences. On the phone this week, he was the same: calm, precise and thoroughly unimpressed with Budget 2026.

“Carney is borrowing and spending way more money than Mr. Trudeau did,” he says. “That’s a quantifiable fact. The numbers tell the story.”

Deficits under Carney are roughly double those in Justin Trudeau’s final budget, and a growing share of the spending is being shoved off the main balance sheet into new Crown corporations and funds. Government debt is rising more than twice as fast as the annual deficit.

Budget 2026, tabled Nov. 5, has been called “more of the same.” Chong’s verdict is sharper: Carney has doubled down. This is his second budget; it’s not a minority Parliament anymore, he’s got a solid majority. And he’s still borrowing and spending ever-increasing amounts of money.

The clearest warning light is the interest bill. A few years ago debt service ate five or six cents of every federal tax dollar. Today it is about 11 cents — roughly $60 billion a year, already more than the entire Canada Health Transfer. By 2030 it is projected to hit 14 cents, or $86 billion. “The fastest-growing expense in the federal government is interest on the national debt,” Chong warns.

Many still buy the image of Carney as the steady CEO who will right the Liberal ship. Chong doesn’t buy it. What he sees is “a big-borrowing, big-spending prime minister. That’s the reality of the government he’s running.”

Skyrocketing debt does more than raise interest costs; it shrinks the fiscal room Ottawa needs when the next crisis hits.

In 2008 the federal government borrowed the equivalent of about five per cent of GDP to get us through the financial crisis.

In the 2020 pandemic, it borrowed closer to 15 per cent.

Today the debt-to-GDP ratio sits near 40 per cent and is climbing toward 50.

“We are reducing the capacity of the federal government to respond to a future crisis — the very thing the prime minister himself says we must be prepared for,” Chong suggests, pointing to Carney’s own national security statement, which warns of the need to be ready for an actual disaster, or actual war. “This budget does not put us on a track to be prepared for it.”

The borrowing also crowds out everyone else. Governments are competing with households and businesses for the same pool of savings, pushing up interest rates for families who need mortgages, car loans, or credit to expand. Massive expansion of federal borrowing is increasing the cost of interest for ordinary Canadians.

Affordability is the daily concern for most people. “Subsidizing, providing more assistance to individuals, to families, to companies, hasn’t worked in the past, and it isn’t going to work going forward,” Chong says.

He says there is one statistic that pops out for him: “We’re now on the third increase to the groceries and essentials benefit, and yet food bank usage this year is at record high levels. Some 2.35 million Canadians, this month, will visit a food bank.”

The solution, he offers, is to create the conditions for incomes and paycheques to grow faster than the cost of living.

That means supply-side reforms: major tax changes, a serious overhaul of competition rules, regulatory cleanup that covers not just big resource projects but small and medium-sized businesses, and the removal of interprovincial barriers.

“We’re seeing the biggest expansion of the federal government … in decades under Mr. Carney,” Chong asserts, “the government is now starting to get involved in areas of our lives that it never previously was involved with ... crowding out private initiatives and private investment.”

He posits: If some companies are getting massive subsidies, how can companies that don’t get those subsidies compete? “The short answer is they can’t.”

The government’s planned equity stake of up to $1.6 billion in Cohere, the Canadian AI company, is a case in point.

“More money has been raised for AI in the last couple of years in the private sector than for almost anything else in recent decades,” he says, arguing the government is inserting itself into a space the private sector has been perfectly capable of funding.

Crown corporations are not new, but “they’ve never been so massively expanded and so filled with public money as we’ve seen in the last 18 months,” Chong suggests. Tens of billions — and potentially hundreds of billions over the next several years — are being borrowed outside the normal budget process. That is not only a fiscal problem, it is a democratic one, he says.

“Parliament’s responsibility is to hold the government democratically accountable for the public purse, for taxation, for spending. It’s sacrosanct. It’s one of the reasons Parliament came into existence.”

**

After a federal budget is released, any Canadian should be able to get a straight answer to two questions: how much new money is Ottawa borrowing; and how much does it owe in total? Budget 2026 has answers, but they're buried, and it spotlights the smallest numbers. If you're not well-versed in public finance, you can be misled into believing Ottawa has much more room to spend than it actually does.

Take the headline deficit, which draws much attention. It's $62 billion in 2026-27, or 1.8 per cent of the economy. But this is a smidgen of the government's new borrowing. Tucked away in a separate table, the budget shows a cash requirement of $149.5 billion, more than double the deficit, or about 4.4 per cent of the economy.

Across the five-year plan, deficits add up to $289 billion, while cash requirements come to $765 billion. The deficit captures less than 40 per cent of the cash Ottawa needs to raise.

Driving the difference is spending recorded outside the deficit, including nearly $180 billion over five years for buildings, ships, aircraft and military vehicles, plus about $300 billion in loans and investments, most of it to Crown corporations.

While some of those dollars create assets and some will be repaid, Ottawa still borrows all of it and pays interest on it in the meantime. Canadians are left without a clear read on what the deficit means.

The Carney government's new practice of sorting spending into capital and operating budgets creates more confusion.

Separating everyday costs from long-term investments can make sense (think: mortgage versus credit card debt). But it all depends on how you define an investment. Ottawa stretches the definition to cover measures like tax breaks, which are actually lost operating revenue, not public investments.

Calling a tax break an investment lets the government claim its new "operating budget" will be balanced in 2027-28, despite ongoing deficits and new borrowing. Even the Parliamentary Budget Officer has called the framework's definition "overly expansive" and broader than international practice.

The low-balling continues with debt, which can be measured in several ways, resulting in different conclusions.

 

Also:

The Canadian Armed Forces have failed another audit over poor record keeping. Auditors in the latest investigation found clerks were still using paper forms to track millions’ worth of sales in canteens and kit shops: “Site visits identified recurring inventory discrepancies.” 

** 

I read that as Chinese investment:

Cabinet will seek foreign investment to help solve the housing crisis, Housing Minister Gregor Robertson said yesterday. A current partial ban on foreign purchase of residential real estate will be extended but with an exemption that “invites investment,” he said: “We will in the new year launch a new process of looking at exemptions for foreign investment in new housing so that we have foreign buyers or investors coming and creating new housing stock.”

 

 

 

No comments: